Storm Damage?
Call 24/7 for Emergency Service: 813-808-ROOF(7663)
Get a Free Quote

How To Choose a Roofing Contractor

Hiring a roofer is a high‑stakes decision. A quality roof protects your home for decades; a bad install can leak from day one. Use this step‑by‑step guide to compare contractors, avoid scams, and choose the right partner for your project. We’ve included a printable scorecard, a bid comparison checklist, and clear red‑flag tests you can apply the same day.

1) Verify the Essentials

Before you look at prices, confirm the basics:

  • Active license & local presence. Ask for license number and a local address you can visit. Drive by a couple of recent jobs from their project gallery.
  • Insurance proof. Require current general liability and workers’ comp certificates—issued to you as certificate holder. No proof, no deal.
  • Written scope. Professional estimates list materials, quantities, and installation details (underlayment, flashing, ventilation). Compare with our roofing services overview.

Quick test: Ask the contractor to email certificates directly from their agent while you are on the call. If they hesitate or send outdated docs, stop there.

2) Make Bids Comparable (Apples to Apples)

Create one common scope and have every contractor price the same work. Use this list to standardize quotes:

  • Tear‑off layers and disposal method
  • Deck repair allowance (per sheet price and max sheets)
  • Underlayment type (synthetic, ice/water shield) and coverage areas
  • Flashing plan (step, counter, chimney, pipe boots) and metals used
  • Ventilation design (ridge vs. box, intake vs. exhaust) and drip edge
  • Material system and warranty level (see roof replacement)
  • Site protection and cleanup (magnet sweep, landscape protection)

Tip: A suspiciously low bid usually leaves out line items you’ll pay for later via change orders.

3) Ask These Questions

  • Who supervises the crew on site? Are they employees or subcontractors? How many years with your company?
  • How will you protect landscaping, AC units, and pools? What’s the daily cleanup plan?
  • What happens if decking is rotten? How is it priced per sheet, and who approves overages?
  • What wind rating will my system meet? (Critical in storm‑prone areas.)
  • What is the workmanship warranty length and what voids it?
  • Can I see photos of similar jobs in the area and read your testimonials?

4) Confirm Installation Standards

Good materials fail when installed poorly. Look for these non‑negotiables:

  • Correct fastener type, count, and pattern per manufacturer spec
  • Closed vs. woven valleys chosen for your material and roof pitch
  • Step‑flashing at walls (no caulk substitutes) and new counter‑flashing where required
  • Proper starter course, ridge cap system, and sealed penetrations
  • Balanced intake/exhaust ventilation; verify net free area math

5) Understand Warranties

Two layers protect you—get both in writing and keep copies in your home file:

  • Manufacturer (product) warranty. Covers defects in shingles/panels. Often tiered by system components.
  • Contractor (workmanship) warranty. Covers installation errors. Confirm term length, exclusions, and whether it’s transferable if you sell.

If anyone promises a “lifetime roof,” ask for the exact document and what “lifetime” means (owner’s lifetime, product lifetime, or pro‑rated schedule).

6) Watch for Red Flags (and How to Test Them)

  • Pressure after storms or offers to “cover your deductible.” → Ask for the written policy on deductibles; legitimate companies won’t promise this.
  • No physical address or permits they can show. → Ask for the last three permit numbers they pulled in your city.
  • One‑line estimate with no scope. → Request a detailed line‑item proposal; if they refuse, walk.
  • Large cash deposit before permits/materials are confirmed. → Standard deposits are modest and tied to milestones.

See more pitfalls in our guide to avoiding roofing scams.

7) Permits, Codes, and Inspections

Your contractor should handle permits and final inspections. Expect clarity on:

  • Where ice/water shield is required (valleys, eaves, penetrations)
  • Underlayment and fastener specs for your material
  • Ventilation ratios based on attic volume and intake/exhaust balance
  • Documentation for any code‑required upgrades added to the scope

Unsure what applies to your home? Start with a documented roof inspection and a clear written scope.

8) Payment Schedule & Timeline

Fair terms protect both parties. A practical example:

  • Deposit: after contract and materials are confirmed
  • Progress: after tear‑off/deck review and material delivery
  • Final: after completion, walkthrough, and punch‑list items are resolved

Need budget flexibility? Review our financing options.

9) Storm Damage & Insurance Claims

If your project is storm‑related, involve a contractor who can meet your adjuster and write supplements with proper documentation. Start with:

For active leaks, request emergency tarping and keep receipts; mitigation is often required by your policy.

10) Aftercare: Maintenance & Warranty Protection

Plan for the next decade on day one:

  • Schedule annual or post‑storm roof maintenance
  • Keep gutters clear; trim overhanging branches
  • Document everything with dated photos for warranty/insurance files

For ongoing tips, browse our roofing resources hub.

Ready for a Bid You Can Trust?

ERS Contractor installs and services residential and commercial roofing with clear scopes, clean jobsites, and responsive communication.

Contact ERS Contractor

Address: 209 Crystal Grove Blvd STE 102, Lutz, FL 33548
Phone: (813) 808-7663

Ready to Protect Your Tampa Bay Roof Today?

Ready for an honest, high-quality roofing partner in the Tampa Bay region? Contact ERS Roof Repair today at 813-808-7663 or visit our contact page to schedule your free inspection. Don’t wait until the next heavy storm hits; let us protect your roof and your investment.